Selecting an Optical Mirror

Optical MirrorOptical mirrors are used in a wide variety of applications including aerospace, military and commercial avionics, scientific and medical instrumentation, academics and research, and industrial applications. Front surface optical mirrors, also known as first surface optical mirrors, reflect light directly from a metallic coating which is applied to the polished or working surface.

Optical mirrors are polished prior to being coated with a reflective coating. Surface flatness is specified by how many wavelengths of light the surface deviates from a perfect plane. This is measured using either a test plate or an interferometer. Mirrors are designated as having a commercial flatness (1-3 waves per inch) or a precision flatness (1/4 wave, 1/10 wave or 1/20 wave) typically measured at 632.8 nm.

Flatness Error of One Fringe
(1/2 wave)
(top view of optical flat)
Test Piece
Perfectly Flat
(top view of optical flat)

How do I choose the correct optical mirror?

A good understanding of your mirror requirements is essential in reducing costs. For instance, the application of the optical mirror will determine which grade of mirror is appropriate. If accuracy is critical, a precision grade is required. The higher the degree of flatness that is required, the more expensive the mirror. For example, a 1/20 wave mirror will be several times more expensive than a 1/4 wave mirror.

In addition, the material used to manufacture the optical mirror is also determined by the application and influences the final cost. Optical mirrors that are made with lower surface accuracy (1/4 or even 1/10 wave) can be made with less expensive substrates such as borosilicate glass or BK7. Mirrors made to a high degree of flatness (1/20 wave) need to be made from harder and more expensive materials such as fused silica, quartz or ZERODUR©. These materials are necessary in order to hold a high degree of surface accuracy.

Finally, when choosing the correct optical mirror, it is important to carefully consider the type of coating best suited to your application. Optical mirrors can be coated with a variety of metallic coatings either with or without a protective overcoat. Although bare coatings (without a protective overcoat) can provide a higher reflectivity, they are very soft and scratch easily. Metallic coatings with a protective overcoat are somewhat more robust, however care must still be taken when using or cleaning an optical mirror. Coatings can vary greatly in cost and application and requirements must be given careful consideration before purchasing.

Typical optical coatings include: Bare and Protected Aluminum, Bare and Protected Gold, Enhanced Aluminum (one specifically designed for the visible region of the spectrum and one for the ultraviolet region) and Protected Silver. Theoretical reflectivity for these coatings are as follows:

Making the final decision.

Material, accuracy and coating all influence the cost of an optical mirror. Determining the best optical mirror for your application will require you to consider the following:

  • How will the mirror be used? Determine what conditions, such as temperature and exposure to abrasion, the mirror will be subjected to.
  • Material selection. Borosilicate glass offers low expansion and resistance to thermal shock and makes a good all-around mirror substrate. Borosilicate glass is the least expensive of the substrates typically used to fabricate optical mirrors. However, if a high degree of accuracy is required, a more expensive material such as fused silica or ZERODUR© may be required.
  • Determine the correct accuracy needed for your application. The more accurately the surface is polished, the less light loss and light scatter there will be and therefore the sharper the reflection will be. Accuracy is also determined by the aspect ratio of the part being polished. An aspect ratio of 6:1 is common for precision polished mirrors. However, sometimes this is not acceptable for certain applications. Should this be the case, one needs to be aware that as the part becomes thinner and further away from the standard aspect ratio of 6:1, flatness may be sacrificed.
  • Coating selection. When selecting a coating one should consider the wavelength range you are working in and the angle of incidence required. Once this is determined, carefully consider how much (percentage of) reflection is required at the wavelength range and angle of incidence for the application.

Customization. Optical mirrors can be customized to meet unique requirements. Advanced Optics capabilities allow us to drill precision holes, produce beveled substrates, fabricate custom sizes and shapes and provide custom coatings with fast turnaround.